David Byrne’s Broadway Musical Celebrates a Monstrous Fascist
David Byrne’s Broadway musical, “Here Lies Love,” pays homage to the controversial figure of Imelda Marcos, the former First Lady of the Philippines and the wife of dictator Ferdinand Marcos. While some argue that the show is an unequivocal condemnation of the Marcos regime, others believe that it glamorizes fascism and its most pervasive agent, Imelda. The creative team’s attempt to distance itself from this fact through gimmicks and immersive theater experiences is questioned. This article explores the narrative of the musical and highlights the importance of understanding the historical context surrounding Imelda Marcos and the Philippine revolution, urging audiences to engage critically with the show’s portrayal of history.

This image is property of i0.wp.com.
David Byrne’s new Broadway musical, ‘Here Lies Love’
David Byrne’s new Broadway musical, ‘Here Lies Love’ (HLL), tells the story of Imelda Marcos, the former First Lady of the Philippines, and her controversial history. From a young girl to a political behemoth, Imelda Marcos is portrayed through this show as a slippery, soapy pulp fiction character. While the show pays homage to Imelda Marcos, it has received criticism for glamorizing fascism and glossing over her crimes and human rights abuses. The creative team behind the show has attempted to distance themselves from the show’s message, but the underlying theme remains.
Imelda Marcos and her controversial history
Imelda Marcos, the former wife of dictator Ferdinand Marcos Sr., and mother of the current president, Ferdinand Marcos Jr., continues to captivate as the blue ribbon champion of fascist pigs, a convicted human rights criminal, grifter, liable for murder, and political monster. She has remained a prominent figure in Philippine politics, with her presence felt at Malacañang Palace. The show ‘Here Lies Love’ aims to capture the essence of Imelda Marcos and her controversial history, but it has been accused of glamorizing her and the fascism associated with her reign.

This image is property of i0.wp.com.
The creative team’s attempt to distance themselves from the show’s message
Despite the controversial nature of the show, the creative team behind ‘Here Lies Love’ has made efforts to distance themselves from the message it portrays. From the immersive theater experience to the vocalization of an all-Filipino cast and the recruitment of high-profile Filipino producers, the team wants the audience to focus on the production as a piece of art rather than a glorification of fascism. However, these efforts have not been successful in diverting attention from the show’s portrayal of Imelda Marcos and the controversies surrounding her.
Glamorizing fascism and Imelda Marcos
One of the main criticisms of ‘Here Lies Love’ is its glamorization of fascism and its portrayal of Imelda Marcos. The show, through its music and storytelling, presents Imelda Marcos as a larger-than-life character and fails to address the atrocities and human rights abuses committed during her time in power. Instead, it focuses on her rise to prominence and her personal journey, romanticizing her and her involvement in the Marcos regime. This glamorization of fascism has raised concerns among viewers and critics about the ethical implications of portraying such a controversial figure in a positive light.

This image is property of i0.wp.com.
The assimilation of Filipinos
During the press efforts for ‘Here Lies Love,’ the cast and crew highlighted the Filipinos’ ability to assimilate into different cultures and environments. While this may be seen as a positive trait, it is important to consider the context in which this assimilation occurs. The Philippines has a history of colonization and oppression, and the assimilation of Filipinos often comes at a cost, including the loss of language, identity, and cultural heritage. By celebrating assimilation in the show, ‘Here Lies Love’ overlooks the struggles and sacrifices that Filipinos have faced in their history.
The People Power Revolution as a significant moment in history
The People Power Revolution in the Philippines in 1986 is one of the most important uprisings in contemporary global history. It marked a turning point in the fight against dictatorship and authoritarianism, setting an example for other nations facing similar challenges. However, in ‘Here Lies Love,’ the revolution and the Filipino people are relegated to the margins. The focus remains on the politicians and Imelda Marcos, while the voices and experiences of the Filipino people are suppressed. By ignoring the significance of the People Power Revolution, the show misses an opportunity to shed light on a pivotal moment in history and its impact on the Filipino people.

This image is property of i0.wp.com.
The marginalization of the Filipino people in the production
One of the criticisms leveled against ‘Here Lies Love’ is the marginalization of the Filipino people in the production. While an all-Filipino cast is used, their roles are limited to non-speaking parts and supplemental videos and footnotes. The show focuses primarily on the politicians and Imelda Marcos, perpetuating the narrative that Filipino history is shaped by those in positions of power rather than the everyday people. By sidelining the Filipino people, ‘Here Lies Love’ fails to accurately represent the experiences and struggles of the Filipino community.
The historical context of colonization and assimilation
To fully understand the criticisms directed at ‘Here Lies Love,’ it is essential to consider the historical context of colonization and assimilation. The Philippines has a long history of colonization by foreign powers, including Spain and the United States. This history has had a profound impact on Filipino culture, identity, and the collective psyche. By ignoring this history and presenting assimilation as a positive aspect, the show overlooks the trauma and struggles that colonization has imposed on the Filipino people.

This image is property of i0.wp.com.
David Byrne’s exhibition of photographs
Accompanying the show is an exhibition of David Byrne’s photographs from a visit to the Santo Nino Shrine Heritage Museum, commonly known as the Imelda Marcos Museum, in Tacloban, Philippines. The photographs, presented as original artworks, depict a carefully constructed narrative that aligns with the propaganda created by the Marcos regime. This exhibition, much like the show itself, blurs the line between fact and fiction, presenting a skewed version of history to the audience.
The construction of a narrative through propaganda
‘Here Lies Love’ and the accompanying exhibition of photographs perpetuate a narrative constructed through propaganda. Both the show and the photographs present a curated version of history, focusing on the glamorous aspects and downplaying the controversies and human rights abuses associated with Imelda Marcos and the Marcos regime. By presenting this narrative as the truth, the show and the exhibition contribute to the distortion of history and the perpetuation of false narratives.
Audience participation and response
Immersive theater encourages audience participation, and ‘Here Lies Love’ is no exception. At the end of the show, the audience is invited to make the letter L with their fingers as a symbol of resistance. This act of participation allows the audience to engage with the themes of the show and make their voices heard. However, it is essential to question whether this act of participation is enough to address the concerns raised about the show’s portrayal of Imelda Marcos and the glamorization of fascism.
The fight against injustice and oppression
Despite the criticisms directed at ‘Here Lies Love,’ it is crucial to recognize that the fight against injustice and oppression continues. The show may present a problematic interpretation of history, but it also serves as a starting point for discussions about the complexities of power, propaganda, and the responsibility of artists. By engaging with the show and challenging its message, audiences can contribute to a deeper understanding of the historical context and work towards a more inclusive and accurate representation of the Filipino people and their struggle for justice. The fight against injustice and oppression is ongoing, and ‘Here Lies Love’ serves as a reminder that there is still work to be done. By standing up against the glamorization of fascist regimes and demanding a more nuanced portrayal of history, we can strive towards a more just and inclusive society.

