Jim Mangan’s Meditation on Religious Succession, Zealotry and Fraternity
In American photographer Jim Mangan’s series, “The Crick,” he explores the lives of a group of teenage boys living in the aftermath of the imprisonment of their religious leader. The boys, who remained in their community, find solace in exploring the rugged landscapes of Utah, Arizona, and Nevada on horseback, mirroring the explorers of the Western frontier. Mangan’s photographs capture the playfulness and resilience of youth against the backdrop of the American West, highlighting the boys’ connection to nature and their unconventional upbringing. “The Crick” is a meditation on religious succession, zealotry, and the bonds of brotherhood, and it is a captivating glimpse into a unique and alternative reality.
Jim Mangan’s Meditation on Religious Succession, Zealotry and Fraternity

Introduction to Jim Mangan’s project
Jim Mangan, an American photographer, embarked on a unique project called The Crick, which serves as a meditation on religious succession, zealotry, and fraternity. Initially, Mangan intended to photograph the unorthodox architecture of houses belonging to the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (FLDS) in the town of Short Creek, located on the Utah-Arizona border. However, he soon realized that the true essence of the project lay in the lives of a group of teenage boys navigating the complexities of their community. This article will delve into the various themes explored in Mangan’s work and analyze the impact it has had on the art and photography community.
The Crick as a survey of FLDS houses in Short Creek
One of the notable aspects of Jim Mangan’s project is the exploration of the architecture found in the houses of the FLDS community in Short Creek. Mangan’s photographs provide an intimate look into the unorthodox designs and structures that form an integral part of the religious succession in the community. Through his lens, Mangan captures the unique blend of tradition and innovation that can be seen in these houses, offering viewers a glimpse into the religious practices and beliefs of the FLDS community.
The bigger story of teenage boys navigating their community
While initially focused on the architectural aspects of the FLDS community, Jim Mangan quickly realized that the real narrative lay in the lives of the teenage boys within the community. These boys were forced to navigate the complexities of a community that had been fractured and disintegrated after the imprisonment of their leader, Warren Jeffs, in 2011. Mangan’s photographs offer a poignant portrayal of these boys as they grapple with the aftermath of the fallout, showcasing their resilience and strength amidst challenging circumstances.

The fallout after Warren Jeffs’ imprisonment
The arrest and imprisonment of Warren Jeffs, the leader of the FLDS community, had a profound impact on the lives of its members. The fallout from Jeffs’ imprisonment created a rift within the community, with some families choosing to remain in Short Creek, while others decided to leave. Mangan’s photographs capture the aftermath of this division, providing an emotional and thought-provoking glimpse into the lives of those affected by the changing dynamics and power struggles within the community.
Children who stayed in Short Creek vs those who left
Among the various narratives depicted in Jim Mangan’s work, a key theme is the distinction between the children who chose to stay in Short Creek and those who left. Mangan’s photographs beautifully portray the resilience and determination of those who stayed behind, highlighting their sense of belonging and commitment to their families and community. Conversely, through the lens of those who left, he captures the complexities of their decision and the challenges they face as they redefine their identities and seek a sense of belonging elsewhere.
Themes in Jim Mangan’s work
Jim Mangan’s project, The Crick, explores several interconnected themes that revolve around religious succession, zealotry, and fraternity. These themes not only shed light on the individual experiences of the boys within the FLDS community but also provide a broader perspective on the dynamics and intricacies of religious communities.

Religious succession in the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints
One of the central themes in Jim Mangan’s work is religious succession within the FLDS community. Through his photographs, Mangan captures the rituals and practices associated with the passing of leadership and the broader impact it has on the community. His images provide insight into the complexities of religious succession, offering viewers a deeper understanding of the FLDS community and its unique structures of authority.
Patriarchal systems within the FLDS community
Another significant theme explored in Jim Mangan’s work is the existence of patriarchal systems within the FLDS community. Through his photographs, Mangan examines the power dynamics and gender roles that shape the lives of community members. By depicting the lived experiences of both boys and girls within this patriarchal framework, Mangan prompts viewers to confront and question the societal norms and expectations perpetuated by these systems.
Exploring zealotry and its impact on the lives of the boys
Zealotry is a key theme in Mangan’s work, as he seeks to understand and depict how religious fervor and zeal influence the lives of the boys within the FLDS community. Through his lens, he captures their devotion and commitment to their faith, while also interrogating the potential pitfalls of zealous belief systems. The photographs serve as a testament to the complex interplay between religious conviction and personal identity.

Fraternity and community-building among the boys
Finally, Mangan’s project delves into the idea of fraternity and community-building among the boys of the FLDS community. Despite the challenges they face, the boys form deep bonds and rely on each other for support and companionship. Mangan’s photographs beautifully capture the sense of camaraderie and shared experiences among these boys, providing a testament to the power of friendship and solidarity in the face of adversity.
The Crick as a meditation on religious succession
Beyond capturing the intricacies of the FLDS community, The Crick serves as a meditation on religious succession itself. Mangan’s photographs transcend the immediate context of Short Creek, inviting viewers to reflect on the broader implications of religious leadership and the impact it has on individuals and communities. By juxtaposing images of religious rituals and ceremonies with the personal narratives of the boys, Mangan encourages contemplation and exploration of the universal themes present in his work.
Depicting the playfulness of youth against the landscape of the American West
One of the distinctive aspects of Jim Mangan’s approach in The Crick is his portrayal of the boys’ playfulness amidst the rugged landscape of the American West. Through his lens, Mangan captures moments of joy, imagination, and curiosity as the boys explore their surroundings on horseback. These images provide a stark contrast to the challenges and complexities they face within their community, offering viewers a glimpse into the resilience and spirit of youth.

Jim Mangan’s ecological and sociological approach to the series
Mangan’s approach to The Crick is characterized by an ecological and sociological lens. In documenting the lives of the boys, he goes beyond surface-level observations and provides an in-depth exploration of the ecological and sociological factors that shape their experiences. Through his photographs, Mangan prompts viewers to reflect on the intricate connections between individuals, communities, and nature.
The boys’ alternate reality and their exploration of the rugged terrain
In The Crick, Mangan transports viewers into an alternate reality created by the boys themselves. Through his photographs, he captures their explorations of the rugged terrain of southern Utah, northern Arizona, and southern Nevada. The boys emulate the old-time explorers of the Western frontier, blurring the boundaries between reality and imagination. Mangan’s photographs beautifully depict the boys’ sense of adventure and their yearning for freedom within the confines of their community.
Gaining knowledge of nature and closeness to the environment
One of the profound impacts of the boys’ exploration of the rugged terrain is their gained knowledge of nature and closeness to the environment. Mangan’s photographs invite viewers to contemplate the transformative power of nature and the ways in which it can shape identity and perspective. The boys’ experiences serve as a reminder of the importance of reconnecting with the natural world in an increasingly urbanized and technologically driven society.
Publication and reception of The Crick
The Crick was published by Twin Palms, a renowned publishing house known for its commitment to photography and art. The publication of the book allowed Mangan’s work to reach a wider audience and sparked critical discussions about the themes explored in the series.
The book’s publication by Twin Palms
Twin Palms, known for its discerning approach to photography book publishing, embraced The Crick as a significant addition to their collection. The publication showcased Mangan’s nuanced and thoughtful portrayal of religious succession, zealotry, and fraternity. Twin Palms recognized the importance of Mangan’s work, ensuring that it reached an audience eager to engage with the photographer’s exploration of these compelling themes.
Critical reception and reviews of Jim Mangan’s work
The Crick received critical acclaim and garnered attention from art and photography critics. Reviewers praised Mangan’s ability to capture the emotional depth and complexity of the boys’ experiences, as well as his skill in addressing the broader themes of religious succession, zealotry, and fraternity. The photographs were commended for their evocative power and thought-provoking nature.
Related articles and projects by Jim Mangan
In addition to The Crick, Jim Mangan has worked on other photo series exploring religious themes. These projects provide further insight into Mangan’s creative exploration of spirituality and its impact on individuals and communities.
Other photo series exploring religious themes
Mangan’s other photo series delve into the intersection of religion and personal identity, further expanding on the themes explored in The Crick. By examining various religious practices and traditions, Mangan offers a multifaceted understanding of the ways in which spirituality shapes individuals and communities.
Collaborations with other artists or photographers
Jim Mangan has also collaborated with other artists and photographers, further enriching his body of work. These collaborations serve as opportunities for Mangan to explore new perspectives and push the boundaries of his creative practice. By engaging in fruitful partnerships, Mangan continues to evolve as an artist and contribute to the ongoing dialogue within the art and photography community.
Conclusion and impact of Jim Mangan’s work
Jim Mangan’s project, The Crick, has had a profound impact on the art and photography community. Through his thoughtful and evocative exploration of religious succession, zealotry, and fraternity, Mangan has sparked discussions and debates surrounding these themes. His photographs serve as a powerful testament to the resilience and strength of the boys within the FLDS community, while also prompting viewers to reflect on their own experiences and beliefs. By inviting contemplation and dialogue, Jim Mangan’s work continues to resonate with audiences and influence the art world at large.

