From the Wire

Moss-Covered Activists Protest Penn Station Neighborhood Over-Development

A thought-provoking public art project, titled “The Keepers,” has taken center stage in the Penn Station neighborhood to raise awareness about the over-development and potential demolition of historical sites. These moss-covered beings, known as the Keepers, appeared silently and slowly on West 32nd Street, drawing attention to culturally significant locations threatened by the Pennsylvania Station Area Civic and Land Use Improvement Project. The project combines performance with photography and is the brainchild of Ed Woodham, the director of the renowned Art in Odd Places festival, in collaboration with the nonprofit Preservation League of New York State. By highlighting issues of gentrification and environmental threats, “The Keepers” aims to spark conversations about sustainable development and the preservation of urban heritage.

Moss-Covered Activists Protest Penn Station Neighborhood Over-Development

This image is property of i0.wp.com.

The Keepers: Moss-Covered Activists

A new public art project, known as “The Keepers,” has emerged in the Pennsylvania Station neighborhood to bring attention to the over-development and demolishment of historical sites. The project aims to shed light on the impacts of the Pennsylvania Station Area Civic and Land Use Improvement Project, which threatens to displace residents and demolish numerous small businesses in the area. This comprehensive article will explore the background of the project, the collaboration with the Empire Station Coalition, the description of the neighborhood’s over-development, the impact on historical buildings and small businesses, the community organizers’ protests, the details of The Keepers’ performance installation, the purpose of The Keepers in raising awareness of urban issues, the ongoing lawsuit against the State of New York, the luxury high-rise plans by Vornado Realty, statements and reactions from key stakeholders, and public reactions to The Keepers’ installation.

Background of the project

The Keepers is a public art project commissioned by the nonprofit Preservation League of New York State. It was created by Ed Woodham, the director of the long-running public art festival Art in Odd Places (AiOP). The project combines performance art with photography to bring awareness to issues of gentrification, environmental threats, and over-development in urban areas. The Keepers are imagined as otherworldly beings who maintain the sacred balance of nature and aim to protect historical sites from demolition. Previous editions of The Keepers have been held in various locations globally, including Brooklyn, Queens, New Jersey, Australia, and Poland.

Collaboration with the Empire Station Coalition

The Keepers project is in collaboration with the Empire Station Coalition, a group of civic organizations opposed to the government’s plan for the Pennsylvania Station neighborhood. The coalition proposes renovating and repurposing the existing infrastructure to create a more inclusive and sustainable public atmosphere. In late 2022, the coalition, along with other groups, sued the State of New York, alleging a violation of the State Environmental Quality Review Act. The coalition argues that the state’s redevelopment plan, which coincides with Amtrak’s multi-billion dollar Gateway Program initiative and Vornado Realty’s luxury high-rise plans, neglects the existing neighborhood and its historical significance.

Moss-Covered Activists Protest Penn Station Neighborhood Over-Development

This image is property of i0.wp.com.

The Penn Station Neighborhood Over-Development

The Pennsylvania Station Area Civic and Land Use Improvement Project, proposed by Empire State Development, seeks to expand Pennsylvania Station and revitalize the Midtown area. However, community organizers have raised concerns about the project’s impact on historical buildings and small businesses. According to data compiled by these organizers, the project would displace over 2,000 residents and eliminate more than 1,300 small businesses in the neighborhood. The over-development and demolishment of historical sites in the Pennsylvania Station neighborhood have sparked protests and criticisms from community activists.

Description of the Pennsylvania Station Area Civic and Land Use Improvement Project

The Pennsylvania Station Area Civic and Land Use Improvement Project aims to expand Pennsylvania Station and revitalize the Midtown area. The project, proposed by Empire State Development, envisions a redevelopment plan that includes the construction of luxury high-rises and the transformation of the neighborhood’s infrastructure. While the project promises to bring changes and improvements to the area, community organizers argue that it neglects the existing historical buildings and small businesses, resulting in widespread displacement and loss of community identity.

Impact on historical buildings and small businesses

The Pennsylvania Station Area Civic and Land Use Improvement Project has raised concerns about the impact on historical buildings and small businesses in the neighborhood. According to data compiled by community organizers, the project would lead to the demolition of numerous historical sites and the displacement of residents and businesses. This has sparked outrage among preservation advocates and community members who value the neighborhood’s cultural and historical significance.

Moss-Covered Activists Protest Penn Station Neighborhood Over-Development

This image is property of i0.wp.com.

Community organizers protesting the state plan

Community organizers have taken a stand against the state plan for the Pennsylvania Station neighborhood. They have organized protests and demonstrations to raise awareness about the potential consequences of the project. These organizers believe that the redevelopment plan neglects the interests of the community and prioritizes large-scale development over the preservation of historical sites and small businesses. They are actively advocating for alternative approaches to urban development that focus on inclusivity, sustainability, and community engagement.

The Keepers’ Performance Installation

The Keepers’ performance installation took place in the Pennsylvania Station neighborhood, specifically outside culturally significant sites like the Gimbel’s Skybridge, the Church of St. John the Baptist, and the ruins of the Hotel Pennsylvania. The performers, dressed as moss-covered beings, moved around the neighborhood in a slow and deliberate manner. Their presence was intended to draw attention to the threatened sites and the broader issue of over-development. Community organizers joined the performance, carrying protest signs to further amplify the message.

Location and timing of the installation

The Keepers’ performance installation began in the early morning hours of Friday, September 22. It started at the Church of St. John the Baptist and continued throughout the neighborhood outside Pennsylvania Station. The chosen sites held cultural significance and were at risk of demolition under the state’s redevelopment plan. The timing of the installation aimed to capture the attention of passersby and raise awareness about the ongoing issues in the neighborhood.

Moss-Covered Activists Protest Penn Station Neighborhood Over-Development

This image is property of i0.wp.com.

Description of the performers and their movement around the neighborhood

The performers involved in The Keepers’ installation were dressed as moss-covered beings. Their appearance was designed to evoke a sense of nature and connection to the environment. Throughout the performance, the performers moved in a slow and deliberate manner, drawing attention to themselves and the threatened sites. Their movement symbolized the importance of preserving historical buildings and the need to protect the neighborhood’s cultural heritage.

Community organizers carrying protest signs

Alongside the performers, community organizers joined The Keepers’ installation, carrying signs protesting the state’s redevelopment plan. These signs had messages that emphasized the importance of preserving historical sites, supporting small businesses, and promoting a more inclusive and sustainable approach to urban development. The presence of community organizers allowed for a unified voice in opposing the state’s plan and advocating for alternative solutions.

The Purpose of The Keepers

The Keepers project aims to bring awareness to issues of gentrification, environmental threats, and over-development through a combination of performance art and photography. By highlighting threatened historical sites and the impact of large-scale development, The Keepers seeks to spark conversations and mobilize communities to take action. Through their performances, The Keepers aim to create a sense of shared responsibility for preserving cultural heritage and advocating for more sustainable and inclusive approaches to urban development.

Moss-Covered Activists Protest Penn Station Neighborhood Over-Development

This image is property of i0.wp.com.

Combining performance and photography

The Keepers project combines performance art with photography to capture and document the ephemeral nature of the performances. The photographs taken during the installations serve as a visual record of the project and its engagement with the neighborhood. Through performance and photography, The Keepers hope to create a lasting impact and raise awareness long after the installations have concluded.

Raising awareness of gentrification, environmental threats, and over-development

The overarching purpose of The Keepers is to raise awareness of the negative impacts of gentrification, environmental threats, and over-development in urban areas. The project aims to shed light on the consequences of prioritizing large-scale development over the preservation of historical sites, community identity, and sustainable urban planning. By engaging with the public through performances and photography, The Keepers encourage dialogue and inspire action towards more inclusive and responsible urban development practices.

Previous locations of The Keepers’ performances

The Keepers’ project has been held in various locations globally, highlighting different sites threatened by gentrification and over-development. Past editions of The Keepers have taken place in Woodham’s former neighborhood of Gowanus in Brooklyn, Jackson Avenue in Long Island City, Queens, Asbury Park in New Jersey, as well as several sites in Australia and Poland. Each location presented unique challenges and issues related to urban development, prompting The Keepers to adapt their performances and advocacy efforts accordingly.

Empire Station Coalition’s lawsuit against the State of New York

The Empire Station Coalition, along with other groups, filed a lawsuit against the State of New York in response to the Pennsylvania Station redevelopment plan. The lawsuit alleges that the State violated the State Environmental Quality Review Act by separately proposing its redevelopment plan alongside Amtrak’s Gateway Program initiative and Vornado Realty’s luxury high-rise plans. The coalition argues that the redevelopment plan neglects the existing neighborhood and its historical significance, favoring large-scale development without considering the environmental and social impacts.

Allegations of violation of the State Environmental Quality Review Act

The lawsuit filed by the Empire Station Coalition alleges a violation of the State Environmental Quality Review Act by the State of New York. The coalition argues that the State failed to conduct a thorough environmental impact assessment and neglected the preservation of historical sites in its redevelopment plan. The violation of the State Environmental Quality Review Act raises concerns about the lack of comprehensive planning and assessment of the project’s long-term effects on the neighborhood and its residents.

Vornado Realty’s luxury high-rise plans

In addition to the State’s redevelopment plan, Vornado Realty has its own plans to build luxury high-rises in the Pennsylvania Station neighborhood. These plans, which coincide with the State’s proposal, further contribute to concerns about over-development and the displacement of residents and small businesses. The luxury high-rise development by Vornado Realty has drawn criticism from community organizers and advocacy groups who argue for a more sustainable and inclusive approach to urban development in the neighborhood.

Governor Kathy Hochul and Empire State Development’s response

The article reached out to Governor Kathy Hochul and Empire State Development for their response to the ongoing lawsuit and the development plans for the Pennsylvania Station neighborhood. As of the writing of this article, no official statements have been provided by Governor Kathy Hochul or Empire State Development. Their perspectives on the lawsuit and development plans are crucial in understanding the governmental response to the concerns raised by the community and The Keepers’ project.

Sam Turvey’s criticism of the developers

Sam Turvey, one of the coordinators of the Empire Station Coalition, expressed strong criticism against the developers involved in the Pennsylvania Station redevelopment plan. Turvey argues that the developers lack an understanding of urbanism and are responsible for the negative impacts and blight in the neighborhood. Turvey believes that the developers prioritize their own interests over the well-being and preservation of the community.

Public reactions to The Keepers’ installation

The installation of The Keepers in the Pennsylvania Station neighborhood has garnered public reactions, sparking curiosity and confusion among passersby. The presence of the moss-covered beings and the community organizers with protest signs drew attention to the ongoing issues in the neighborhood. The public’s reactions to The Keepers’ installation contribute to a broader dialogue about the impacts of over-development and the preservation of historical sites in urban areas.

In conclusion, The Keepers project, in collaboration with the Empire Station Coalition, seeks to raise awareness of the over-development and demolishment of historical sites in the Pennsylvania Station neighborhood. Through performance and photography, The Keepers aim to highlight issues of gentrification, environmental threats, and the negative consequences of large-scale development. The ongoing lawsuit against the State of New York and the luxury high-rise plans by Vornado Realty add to the concerns raised by community organizers and advocacy groups. The public’s reactions to The Keepers’ installation contribute to a broader conversation about urban development, preservation, and community engagement. It is essential to consider alternative approaches to urban development that prioritize inclusivity, sustainability, and the preservation of cultural heritage in order to create more resilient and vibrant neighborhoods.

Source: https://hyperallergic.com/846326/moss-covered-activists-protest-penn-station-neighborhood-over-development/

LookCreativity

LookCreativity

Hello, We're Look, Creativity, the authors behind this vibrant website - Look, Creativity. Welcome to Your Lens to the Creative World! As an enthusiast of art and design, we're here to guide you through the captivating realm of creativity. With a keen eye for the latest trends and news, we curate inspiring content and present handpicked products specifically tailored for today's designers and creators.