Newfields, Still Reeling from Controversy, Names Indianapolis Museum Director After Lengthy Search
Newfields, the Indianapolis Museum of Art at Newfield, has announced the appointment of Belinda Tate as its new director, marking the end of a lengthy search process and a period of controversy for the institution. Tate, who previously served as the executive director of Michigan’s Kalamazoo Institute of Arts, will assume her role on November 6. Alongside the appointment, Newfields introduced the title Melvin & Bren Simon Director, reflecting the museum’s recent executive restructuring. This announcement comes after a tumultuous time for Newfields, including a viral job posting controversy and the resignation of their former CEO and president. Tate’s appointment brings hope for a new era at Newfields, focusing on community engagement, exceptional exhibitions, and inclusivity.

This image is property of www.artnews.com.
Newfields Appoints Belinda Tate as Director
Conclusion of a Lengthy Hiring Process
Newfields has finally concluded its lengthy hiring process by appointing Belinda Tate as the next director of the Indianapolis Museum of Art at Newfield. This appointment comes after nearly four years of searching for the right candidate to lead the institution.
Crisis of Identity for the Institution
During the hiring process, Newfields faced a crisis of identity when a job posting sparked outrage online. The posting had a requirement that the chosen applicant must maintain a “traditional, core, white art audience” while also increasing diversity. This requirement caused a firestorm of controversy and led to widespread criticism of the institution’s values and practices.
Tate’s Background and Experience
Belinda Tate comes to Newfields from Michigan’s Kalamazoo Institute of Arts, where she served as executive director since 2014. With her extensive experience in the arts and cultural sector, Tate brings valuable insights and expertise to her new role as director.
New Title: Melvin & Bren Simon Director
In addition to being appointed as the director, Tate also holds the title of Melvin & Bren Simon Director. This title was established in February 2021 as part of Newfields’ efforts to revamp its executive structure and further align its leadership with its mission and values.
Controversy and Online Outrage
Job Posting Sparks Outrage
One of the major controversies that Newfields faced during its hiring process was sparked by the original job posting. The requirement to maintain a “traditional, core, white art audience” received backlash from the online community, leading to widespread outrage and criticism directed towards the institution.
Requirement to Maintain ‘Traditional, Core, White Art Audience’
The specific requirement in the job posting to maintain a “traditional, core, white art audience” was seen by many as exclusionary and contrary to principles of diversity and inclusivity. This requirement raised concerns about Newfields’ commitment to creating a welcoming and inclusive environment for all visitors.
Resignation of Charles Venable
The controversy surrounding the job posting ultimately led to the resignation of Charles Venable, the then-CEO and president of Newfields. Venable’s departure marked a significant turning point for the institution, as it sought to address the issues raised and move towards a more inclusive and diverse future.
Appointment of Colette Pierce Burnette
Following Charles Venable’s resignation, Colette Pierce Burnette was appointed as his replacement in 2022. Burnette’s appointment signaled Newfields’ commitment to addressing the controversies and working towards a more inclusive and equitable institution under new leadership.

This image is property of www.artnews.com.
Tate’s Appointment and Statement
Tate’s Humility and Excitement for the Opportunity
Belinda Tate expressed her humility and excitement upon being appointed as the director of Newfields. She acknowledged the opportunity to work alongside President and CEO Dr. Colette Pierce Burnette and praised the dedicated team at Newfields.
Joining a Dedicated Team at Newfields
Tate recognized the dedication and passion of the team at Newfields, emphasizing the institution’s commitment to serving the community through exceptional exhibitions and programs. She looks forward to being part of one of the nation’s leading cultural destinations.
Serving the Community as a Cultural Destination
As the new director, Tate sees her role as serving the community and making Newfields a cultural destination that inspires and uplifts visitors. She aims to build on the institution’s stellar collection and continue its legacy of excellence in the arts.
Tate’s Background and Qualifications
Director of Diggs Gallery at Winston-Salem State University
Prior to her appointment at Newfields, Belinda Tate served as the director of the Diggs Gallery at Winston-Salem State University. This experience provided her with valuable insights into curatorial and exhibition practices, as well as the importance of creating inclusive spaces for art.
Service on AAM Task Force on Diversity, Equity, Accessibility, and Inclusion
Tate’s commitment to diversity and inclusion in the arts is further demonstrated by her service on the American Alliance of Museum’s Task Force on Diversity, Equity, Accessibility, and Inclusion in Museum Excellence. Her involvement in this task force highlights her dedication to advancing equitable practices within the museum field.
Relevant Experience for Leading Newfields
With her background in gallery management and her commitment to diversity and inclusion, Belinda Tate brings relevant experience to her new role as director of Newfields. Her qualifications position her well to lead the institution and guide its transformation towards a more inclusive and accessible future.

This image is property of www.artnews.com.
Allegations of Discriminatory Work Culture
Claims of a ‘Toxic’ and Discriminatory Environment
Newfields has faced allegations of a “toxic” and discriminatory work culture, as described in an open letter from Kelli Morgan, the former associate curator of American art. These allegations shed light on the need for significant changes within the institution to address issues of discrimination and create a more inclusive environment for staff.
Open Letter from Former Associate Curator Kelli Morgan
In her open letter, Kelli Morgan detailed her experiences of a discriminatory work culture at Newfields. Her letter served as a call to action to address these issues and work towards a more equitable and supportive environment for all employees.
Description of a ‘Racist Rant’ from a Museum Board Member
Morgan’s letter included a disturbing account of a “racist rant” from a museum board member. This incident highlighted the presence of discriminatory attitudes within the institution’s leadership and the urgent need to address these issues head-on.
Legacy of Charles Venable
Polarizing Vision for Museum Programming
Charles Venable, the former CEO and president of Newfields, had a polarizing vision for the museum’s programming. Critics of Venable argued that he prioritized blockbuster exhibitions over creating a diverse and inclusive museum experience.
Criticism of Prioritizing Blockbuster Exhibitions
Venable’s focus on blockbuster exhibitions received criticism for detracting from the museum’s mission and values. The elevation of high-profile, commercially successful exhibitions was seen by some as a departure from the institution’s commitment to showcasing a broad range of artistic voices and perspectives.
Examples of Controversial Exhibitions and Events
Some of the examples frequently cited as controversial during Venable’s tenure include a show devoted to Bugatti cars and the Winterlights festival. These events raised concerns about the institution’s priorities and whether they truly aligned with the needs and interests of its diverse audience.

This image is property of www.artnews.com.
High Expectations for Tate
Responsibility to Lead the Next Generation of Newfields
As the new director, Belinda Tate has the responsibility to lead the next generation of Newfields and guide the institution towards a more inclusive and equitable future. There are high expectations for her leadership and the positive impact she can make on the institution and the community it serves.
Alignment with Values of Stewardship, Inclusivity, Excellence, and Service
Tate’s appointment is seen as a step towards aligning Newfields’ leadership with its core values of stewardship, inclusivity, excellence, and service. Her commitment to diversity, equality, and inclusion makes her well-suited to guide the institution in transforming its practices and creating a more welcoming space for all.
Recognition of Tate’s Trailblazing Work in Diversity and Inclusion
Belinda Tate’s trailblazing work in diversity and inclusion in the arts has been widely recognized. Her appointment as the director of Newfields is a testament to her accomplishments and the potential she has to drive meaningful change within the institution.
In conclusion, the appointment of Belinda Tate as the new director of Newfields marks a significant turning point for the institution. After a lengthy hiring process and a crisis of identity, Tate brings a fresh perspective and a commitment to diversity and inclusion to her new role. With the support of a dedicated team and a community eager for change, Tate has the opportunity to lead Newfields into a new era of inclusivity, excellence, and service to the community.

