Xaviera Simmons Accuses Queens Museum of Repurposing Her Work Without Permission
In a recent controversy, Xaviera Simmons has accused the Queens Museum of repurposing her artwork without her permission. Simmons, an artist whose solo exhibition was held at the museum, claimed that a freestanding structure she created for the show was painted pink, moved, and used to display works by another artist. Despite expecting the materials to be returned after the exhibition’s closure, Simmons was shocked to see her artwork repurposed for someone else’s exhibition. She demanded that the structure be torn down and removed, which the museum complied with. This incident raises questions about the rights of artists and the responsibilities of institutions to respect and preserve their work.

This image is property of www.artforum.com.
Background
In recent news, artist Xaviera Simmons has accused the Queens Museum of repurposing her work without her permission. Simmons had a solo exhibition at the museum titled ‘Crisis Makes a Book Club’, in which she conceived a site-specific structure for her artwork. The structure consisted of a large walled enclosure with interior videos and exterior panels, creating a unique and immersive experience for viewers.
Xaviera Simmons’ Solo Exhibition
Simmons put a lot of thought and effort into creating the site-specific structure for her exhibition. She wanted to provide a unique and immersive experience for viewers, and the structure was an integral part of her artistic vision. The large walled enclosure housed seven videos by Simmons inside, while the exterior panels featured black panels with white text, including musings on race and excerpts from James Baldwin’s essay. It was a carefully curated and thought-provoking exhibition.

This image is property of www.artforum.com.
The Queens Museum’s Actions
However, after the closure of Simmons’ exhibition, the Queens Museum made the decision to paint the structure pink and repurpose it for another artist’s exhibition, Tracey Rose’s ‘Shooting Down Babylon’. This decision was made without Simmons’ permission or knowledge, leading to her outrage and frustration. She reached out to the museum, demanding that the structure be torn down and that her work not be used without her consent.
Queens Museum’s Explanation
The museum claimed that the reuse of the structure was done in order to conserve materials. According to an assistant curator, repurposing the structure was a way to add less waste to landfills. However, Simmons vehemently disagreed with this explanation and believed that the museum’s actions were a form of gaslighting and an attempt to discredit her work. She questioned whether the museum would have treated famous artists’ works in the same way.

This image is property of www.artforum.com.
Simmons’ Reaction
Simmons expressed her frustration and disappointment with the Queens Museum for their actions. She felt that her artistic vision and consent were not respected, and she believed that no artist should have their work repurposed without their permission. She called out the museum for their response to her request, stating that they took a long time to address her concerns and that their actions undermined her as an artist.
Resolution
After Simmons demanded the removal of the repurposed structure, the museum temporarily closed to comply with her request. They dismantled the structure and built a new one for Tracey Rose’s exhibition. Simmons received photos of the destroyed structure as proof of the museum’s compliance.

This image is property of www.artforum.com.
Simmons’ Statements
Simmons has been vocal about the importance of artists’ consent and the respect that should be given to an artist’s work. She asserts that no artist should have their work repurposed without their consent, and she criticizes the Queens Museum for what she considers to be a disregard for her artistic integrity. Simmons believes that museums should be held accountable for their actions and should prioritize artists’ rights.
Comparisons to Other Artists
Simmons pointed out that she questions whether the museum would have treated works by renowned artists like Joseph Beuys or Donald Judd in the same manner. These artists are known for their minimal and site-specific works, and Simmons believes that their works would have received more respect and consideration. She raises the point that artists should be treated equally and that their consent should be valued, regardless of their level of fame or recognition.

This image is property of www.artforum.com.
Conclusion
Simmons concludes by calling for institutions to respect artists’ work and their consent. She believes that museums have a responsibility to honor and uphold artists’ rights, and she hopes that her experience with the Queens Museum will serve as a reminder of the importance of these values. Despite her frustration with the museum, Simmons acknowledges the significance of her exhibition and the impact it had on viewers.
Implications for Artist-Museum Relationships
This incident raises important questions about power dynamics and artistic control in museum exhibitions. It highlights the need for clear communication and a respectful partnership between artists and museums. Artists should have a say in the use of their work and should be consulted prior to any repurposing or recontextualization. The incident at the Queens Museum serves as a reminder that artists’ rights and consent should always be prioritized in the artist-museum relationship.

