From the Wire

Artist Says Queens Museum Repurposed Her Structure Without Permission

In a recent incident at the Queens Museum in New York, artist Xaviera Simmons has accused the institution of repurposing part of her site-specific installation without her permission. The structure in question, which was the centerpiece of her solo exhibition “Crisis Makes a Book Club,” was removed and returned to Simmons after the show, but the museum decided to use it in a solo exhibition by another artist, Tracey Rose, without consulting Simmons. The museum claimed that they did not anticipate her disapproval and that they repurposed the structure to reduce waste. However, Simmons expressed her disappointment and emphasized that no artist should have their work repurposed without consent. This incident raises questions about the rights and ownership of site-specific installations in art institutions.

Artist Says Queens Museum Repurposed Her Structure Without Permission

Artist Says Queens Museum Repurposed Her Structure Without Permission

This image is property of i0.wp.com.

Overview

Xaviera Simmons, an artist, has recently claimed that the Queens Museum in New York repurposed part of her site-specific installation without her consent. The structure at the center of the controversy was originally created for her installation “Align” as part of her solo exhibition “Crisis Makes a Book Club” at the museum. Simmons has raised concerns about the removal of the painted siding from the structure and its subsequent use in another exhibition without her permission. This article will provide an overview of the issue, including the conception of the art installation, the removal of the siding, Simmons’s demand for removal, the museum’s response and justification, the closure and dismantling of the structure, Simmons’s disapproval, and the significance of the structure.

Conception of the Art Installation

Simmons’s installation, “Align,” was a large walled enclosure with an opening in one wall and a video series playing inside. The exterior of the structure featured black wood panel siding onto which Simmons had written about the origin, nature, and continuity of whiteness. The design of the installation was specifically tailored for the museum’s Central Atrium gallery space, with text panels and exterior features carefully selected to complement the exhibition.

Artist Says Queens Museum Repurposed Her Structure Without Permission

This image is property of i0.wp.com.

Removal of Siding and Return of Content

After the exhibition closed in March, the Queens Museum removed the painted siding from Simmons’s structure. Along with the siding, the museum returned the other contents of her exhibition to her. While Simmons expected the entire structure to be shipped to her storage, she discovered that the museum had decided to keep the structure in place.

Simmons’s Demand for Removal

Upon learning that her structure had been repurposed for another exhibition, Simmons immediately contacted the museum’s curatorial staff to express her desire for it to be taken down. She also sent two letters to the museum’s board of directors demanding the dismantling of her enclosure. Despite Simmons’s requests, the museum did not remove the structure before the opening of the new exhibition, “Shooting Down Babylon.”

Artist Says Queens Museum Repurposed Her Structure Without Permission

This image is property of i0.wp.com.

Museum’s Response and Justification

The Queens Museum responded to Simmons’s concerns by placing a screen in front of her structure to obscure it from view starting on the second day of the new exhibition. The museum justified its decision to repurpose the structure by stating that it intended to reduce waste and reuse parts of exhibits for future use. They emphasized that they complied with Simmons’s request to remove the structure once they became aware of her objections. The museum closed its doors in order to dismantle the structure and built a new enclosure in the same spot.

Closure and Dismantling of Structure

The Queens Museum closed to the public in order to dismantle Simmons’s structure and built a new pink enclosure in its place. The closure lasted from May 1 to May 10, during which time the museum shared photos with Simmons of the work being dismantled. The new enclosure was completed, and the museum reopened to the public with the new exhibition in place.

Artist Says Queens Museum Repurposed Her Structure Without Permission

This image is property of i0.wp.com.

Simmons’s Disapproval and Experience with the Museum

Simmons expressed her surprise and dissatisfaction with the Queens Museum’s decision to repurpose her art without seeking her authorization. As an artist who has worked with museums for decades and showcased various installations, Simmons had never encountered such an issue before. She also mentioned her role as a “co-thinker” for the museum’s YoU residency program and how some artists involved in the program became disillusioned with the museum. The artist felt that the museum’s actions discredited her work and criticized their delayed response to her request for the structure’s removal.

Significance of the Structure

Simmons designed her structure to serve as a “space of pause,” offering a place for reflection and contemplation. It was meant to be grand and overpowering while also providing a moment for introspection. The structure held symbolic meaning and embodied the artist’s conceptual vision, making its repurposing without consent all the more disheartening.

Artist Says Queens Museum Repurposed Her Structure Without Permission

This image is property of i0.wp.com.

Conclusion

From Xaviera Simmons’s perspective, the repurposing of her structure by the Queens Museum without her permission reflects a breach of trust and respect for artists’ work. While the museum eventually complied with her demand for removal, the incident raises questions about artists’ rights and institutional responsibilities. The handling of this situation by the museum has led to disappointment and disillusionment, both for Simmons and for other artists who have participated in the museum’s programs. Moving forward, it is crucial for museums to prioritize effective communication, transparency, and the preservation of artists’ creative integrity.

Source: https://hyperallergic.com/845922/artist-says-queens-museum-repurposed-her-structure-without-permission/

LookCreativity

LookCreativity

Hello, We're Look, Creativity, the authors behind this vibrant website - Look, Creativity. Welcome to Your Lens to the Creative World! As an enthusiast of art and design, we're here to guide you through the captivating realm of creativity. With a keen eye for the latest trends and news, we curate inspiring content and present handpicked products specifically tailored for today's designers and creators.